Comment nous évaluons les appareils :

Un appareil avec le meilleur score coûtera relativement peu à la réparation puisqu'il est facile à démonter et qu'un manuel de réparation est disponible. Les points sont attribués selon la difficulté à ouvrir l'appareil, le type de fixations et la difficulté à remplacer les composants majeurs. Un bonus est accordé pour l'évolutivité, l'utilisation d'outils universels pour l'entretien et la modularité des composants.

Trier par : Date de publication | Score

iPad 6
iPad 6
  • As in all iPads, a solid barrier of very strong adhesive bars the way to any repairs, and makes rework a sticky proposition.
  • More adhesive holds nearly everything else in place. Battery replacement is particularly challenging.
  • The LCD has foam sticky tape adhering it to the front panel, increasing risk of damage during disassembly.

2
Acer Iconia One 7
Acer Iconia One 7
  • LCD and front glass are not fused and can be replaced individually.
  • Battery is easy to replace.
  • High wear components soldered in place, which increases replacement costs.

8
Kindle Paperwhite 7th Generation
Kindle Paperwhite 7th Generation
  • The battery was very easy to remove.
  • All screws were Phillips #00 screws.
  • Thin layer of adhesive that needed to broken in order to remove the bezel and access the internal components.

8
Huawei MediaPad M2
Huawei MediaPad M2
  • The display is easily removed from the simple clips holding it to the body, simplifying repairs.
  • Most components are modular and not overly complex.
  • The battery is extremely difficult to remove, even with heat and prying.

7
Amazon Fire 5th Generation
Amazon Fire 5th Generation
  • The plastic case assembly is held together by clips and no adhesive, and opening only requires prying with an iFixit opening tool.
  • The digitizer and LCD panel are not fused together.
  • Removing the digitizer and LCD panel requires fighting through some very resilient adhesive.

7
HP ElitePad 1000 G2 Teardown
HP ElitePad 1000 G2 Teardown
  • Display is easy to remove and has no adhesive.
  • Most commonly-failing components, including all the ports and buttons and are modular and can be replaced quickly.
  • RAM and SSD are soldered to the motherboard and non-upgradable.

7
Huawei MediaPad T2
Huawei MediaPad T2
  • Rear case is secured by clips, not glue, and is flexible enough to remove fairly easily.
  • Non-proprietary Phillips screws used throughout.
  • Battery is held in place with excessive adhesive. A hole in the midframe means prying the battery out may risk damaging the back of the display.

6
Sony Xperia Z4 Tablet
Sony Xperia Z4 Tablet
  • The delicate and arduous opening procedure leaves no room for mistakes, and must be completed to access any other component.
  • The display assembly consists of a thin fused glass panel and LCD, and is extremely difficult to remove and replace.
  • Many parts are modular and can be replaced independently.

5
Samsung Galaxy Tab S3
Samsung Galaxy Tab S3
  • In order to repair or replace anything, both the front and rear panel need to be removed.
  • The front and rear panel are secured in place with a lot of adhesive, and are extremely hard to remove.
  • Many components (including the headphone jack, speakers, and micro SD slot) are modular and can be replaced.

4
Microsoft Surface Pro 5
Microsoft Surface Pro 5
  • Adhesive holds many components in place, including the display and battery.
  • Replacement of any part requires removal of the display assembly, an easy part to damage.
  • The SSD is no longer replaceable.

1
iPad Pro 10,5"
iPad Pro 10,5"
  • Le panneau frontal fusionné augmente le coût de la réparation de l'écran et le risque d'endommager l'écran LCD lors de l'ouverture.
  • Des monceaux d'adhésif maintiennent le tout en place, augmentant la difficulté de toute réparation.
  • Bien qu'elle ne soit pas soudée en place, la batterie est très solidement collée – ont disparu les languettes d'extraction que nous avons vues dans l'iPad Pro 12.9".

2
LG G Pad 7.0
LG G Pad 7.0
  • Very modular design allows independent replacement of several wear-prone components—like the headphone jack and speakers.
  • Only very mild adhesive holds the battery in place, making it fairly easy to safely remove and replace.
  • Display assembly is a single fused component, that requires disassembling the entire phone to replace.

8
iPad 5 Wi-Fi
iPad 5 Wi-Fi
  • Tout comme dans les iPads précédents, le panneau frontal est collé au reste de l'appareil, augmentant considérablement les chances de fissurer le verre lors d'une réparation.
  • Des monceaux d'adhésif maintiennent le tout en place. Comme son prédécesseur, l'Air 1, il se classe parmi les retraits de batterie les plus difficiles que nous ayons vus dans un iPad.
  • L'écran LCD a une bande adhésive en mousse qui le colle au panneau frontal, ce qui augmente les chances de bris de verre lors du démontage.

2
HP Pro x2 612 G2
HP Pro x2 612 G2
  • Documentation de réparation fournie par le constructeur.
  • Facile à ouvrir.
  • La construction complexe facilite la modularité mais rend la réparation plus difficile que nécessaire.

9
Google Pixel C
Google Pixel C
  • The motherboard is glued tightly to the rear case.
  • Crazy strong adhesive holds the battery to the rear case, complicating the inevitable replacement.
  • Many parts, including the USB-C port, are modular and can be replaced independently.

4
HP Elite x2
HP Elite x2
  • Facile à ouvrir.
  • Design simple, modulaire et sans colle.
  • Documentation de réparation fournie par le constructeur.

10
iPad Pro 9.7"
iPad Pro 9.7"
  • Le panneau frontal fusionné augmente le coût de la réparation de l'écran et le risque d'endommager l'écran LCD lors de l'ouverture.
  • Des monceaux d'adhésif maintiennent le tout en place et rendent toute réparation plus difficile.
  • Bien qu'elle ne soit pas soudée, la batterie est très solidement fixée – les bande d'extraction que nous avons trouvées dans le plus grand iPad Pro 12.9 " ont disparu.

2
iPad Pro 12.9"
iPad Pro 12.9"
  • Le panneau frontal fusionné augmente le coût de la réparation de l'écran et le risque d'endommager l'écran LCD lors de l'ouverture.
  • Des monceaux d'adhésif tiennent le tout en place et rendent toute réparation plus difficile.
  • La batterie n'est pas soudée à la carte logique et peut maintenant être retirée avec des languettes adhésives, ce qui simplifie grandement le retrait de la batterie.

3
Microsoft Surface Pro 4
Microsoft Surface Pro 4
  • The display assembly consists of a fused glass panel and LCD, and is difficult to remove and replace.
  • Adhesive holds many components in place, including the display and battery.
  • The battery is not soldered to the motherboard, but very strong adhesive makes removal and replacement a hazardous chore.

2
iPad mini 4 Wi-Fi
iPad mini 4 Wi-Fi
  • Le panneau frontal fusionné augmente également le coût de la réparation d'un écran craqué ainsi que le risque d'endommager l'écran LCD lors de l'ouverture.
  • Le connecteur de charge Lightning est soudé à la carte mère, ne pliez donc pas ses broches.
  • Des monceaux d'adhésif tiennent le tout en place, ce qui augmente la difficulté de toute réparation.
Kindle Voyage
Kindle Voyage
  • Several modular components can be replaced individually.
  • Screws secure a slide-off rear case, simplifying opening procedure compared to other Kindles.
  • The front glass and e-ink display are fused together, increasing the cost of repairs.

7
Nexus 9
Nexus 9
  • The interior is a maze of tape and thin, delicate cables, making disassembly and reassembly difficult and perilous.
  • The LCD is fused to the front glass, so you'll need to replace both components in the event of a cracked screen.
  • The rear case is secured with clips, so it can be easily removed without heat or tools (just don't lose your rear-facing camera).

3
iPad Mini 3 Wi-Fi
iPad Mini 3 Wi-Fi
  • Copious amounts of adhesive hold many components in place—front glass, battery, front camera, back camera, ribbon cables—making repair extremely difficult.
  • The Lightning connector is soldered to the logic board, so don't bend its pins.
  • Removing the home button is now a much more difficult job. If you want to keep Touch ID functionality after a screen replacement, you'll have to transfer the home button to the new front panel.

2
iPad Air 2
iPad Air 2
  • Le panneau frontal fusionnée augmente également le coût de la réparation d'un écran craqué et le risque d'endommager l'écran LCD lors de l'ouverture.
  • Tout comme dans les iPads précédents, le panneau frontal est collé au reste de l'appareil, de qui augmente considérablement les chances de fissurer le verre lors d'une réparation.
  • Les multiples points d'adhésif tiennent le tout en place et rendent toute réparation plus difficile.

2
Kindle 7th Generation
Kindle 7th Generation
  • Simple, modular design with few, distinct components that can be replaced independently.
  • Easy opening procedure—clips supplemented by mild adhesive are all that hold the front bezel in place.
  • Battery adhesive is much stronger than necessary, making its replacement hazardous.

8
Kindle Fire HD 6
Kindle Fire HD 6
  • The rear case is very easy to open, granting trouble-free access to the internals.
  • All the fasteners found inside are T5 Torx screws—one non-proprietary screwdriver is all you need.
  • The glass panel is fused to the front plastic frame, meaning a heat gun is required for replacing cracked glass (or you have to replace both components together).

6
Microsoft Surface Pro 3
Microsoft Surface Pro 3
  • The display assembly consists of a fused glass panel and LCD, and is extremely difficult to remove and replace.
  • Tons of adhesive hold everything in place, including the display and battery.
  • The delicate and arduous opening procedure leaves no room for mistakes: one slip-up, and you'll be out a screen.

1
iPad Mini 2
iPad Mini 2
  • Des quantités importantes d'adhésif fixent de nombreux composants en place : la vitre frontale, la batterie, la caméra frontale, la caméra arrière, les nappes. Ce qui rend la réparation extrêmement difficile.
  • Le connecteur de charge Lightning est soudé à la carte mère, alors ne pliez pas ses broches.
  • Les vis cachées signifient que vous devrez être très attentif lorsque vous enlèverez les composants internes.

2
Amazon Kindle Fire HDX 8.9"
Amazon Kindle Fire HDX 8.9"
  • La vitre est maintenue en place par des clips.
  • Le design modulaire permet de remplacer plusieurs composants.
  • La batterie est collée et difficile à retirer.

7
iPad Air LTE
iPad Air LTE
  • Just like in previous iPads, the front panel is glued to the rest of the device, greatly increasing the chances of cracking the glass during a repair.
  • Gobs, gobs, and goblins of adhesive hold everything in place. This is the most difficult battery removal procedure we've seen in an iPad.
  • The LCD has foam sticky tape adhering it to the front panel, increasing chances of it being shattered during disassembly.

2
Microsoft Surface Pro 2
Microsoft Surface Pro 2
  • The display assembly consists of a fused glass panel and LCD, and is extremely difficult to remove and replace.
  • Tons of adhesive hold everything in place, including the display and battery.
  • The delicate and arduous opening procedure leaves no room for mistakes: one slip-up, and you'll likely shear one of the four ribbon cables in the edge of the display.

1
Kindle Fire HDX 7"
Kindle Fire HDX 7"
  • The battery is glued in place with strong adhesive and requires motherboard removal to replace.
  • The motherboard is very difficult to replace—the midframe must be separated from the display assembly in order to reinstall it.
  • Several modular components can be replaced individually.

3
Kindle Fire HD 2013
Kindle Fire HD 2013
  • Simple, modular design means the few components that might fail can be easily, inexpensively replaced.
  • All the fasteners found inside are Torx T5 screws—one non-proprietary screwdriver is all you need.
  • A decent amount of adhesive is used on the battery, meaning some prying and gentle working is required for disassembly.

8
Dell XPS 10
Dell XPS 10
  • Facile à ouvrir. La batterie est facile à retirer.
  • Vis à code couleur et câbles étiquetés à l'intérieur.
  • L'écran LCD est collé à la vitre tactile.

9
Microsoft Surface Pro
Microsoft Surface Pro
  • The display assembly (comprising of a fused glass and LCD) is extremely difficult to remove/replace.
  • Tons of adhesive hold everything in place, including the display and battery.
  • Unless you perform the opening procedure 100% correctly, chances are you'll shear one of the four cables surrounding the display perimeter.

1
Amazon Kindle Fire HD 8.9"
Amazon Kindle Fire HD 8.9"
  • Avec seulement quelques clips, l'appareil est très facile à ouvrir.
  • Un pistolet à air chaud est nécessaire pour l'écran LCD et la vitre soudés.
  • La batterie et les câbles sont collés au châssis.

5
Google Nexus 10
Google Nexus 10
  • La batterie est facile à retirer. Le LCD n'est pas collé à la vitre.
  • L'ouverture de l'appareil est une procédure très difficile.
  • Plusieurs composants sont fixés à la fois par des vis et de la colle.

6
iPad Mini Wi-Fi
iPad Mini Wi-Fi
  • Des quantités copieuses d'adhésif maintiennent de nombreux composants en place – vitre frontale, carte mère, batterie, caméra frontale, caméra arrière, nappes – ce qui la réparation extrêmement difficile.
  • Le connecteur de charge Lightning est soudé à la carte mère, alors ne pliez pas ses broches.
  • Les vis cachées signifient que vous devrez être très attentif lorsque vous essayez d'enlever les composants internes.

2
iPad 4 Wi-Fi
iPad 4 Wi-Fi
  • Just like in the iPad 2 & 3, the front panel is glued to the rest of the device, greatly increasing the chances of cracking the glass when trying to remove it.
  • Gobs, gobs, and gobs of adhesive hold everything in place, including the prone-to-start-a-fire-if-punctured battery.
  • The LCD has foam sticky tape adhering it to the front panel, increasing chances of it being shattered during disassembly.

2
Microsoft Surface RT
Microsoft Surface RT
  • It's pretty difficult to remove the rear panel and gain access to the device.
  • It is impossible to remove the keyboard connector without first removing the display from the frame.
  • Several components are modular and replaceable without requiring desoldering.

4
Kindle Fire HD
Kindle Fire HD
  • The rear case is very easy to open, granting trouble-free access to the internals.
  • The battery is held in with absolutely no adhesive.
  • Copper tape over the processor is somewhat difficult to remove and to readhere correctly.

7
Réparation du Nexus 7
Réparation du Nexus 7
  • The rear case is very easy to open, and requires minimal prying effort with a plastic opening tool to remove.
  • All fasteners inside are Phillips #00 screws—no security or proprietary screws here.
  • The LCD does not separate from the display glass, increasing repair costs.

7
Nook Simple Touch with GlowLight
Nook Simple Touch with GlowLight
  • The opening procedure was very simple, and aside from the massive amounts of adhesive, every part came free rather easily.
  • There were a total of only 12 screws (all T5 Torx), 11 of which were the same length.
  • The front glass, GlowLight LEDs, and digitizer are fused together, so breaking any of these parts will require replacement of the entire display assembly.

7
Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 7.0
Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 7.0
  • Un design modulaire et des composants faciles à enlever.
  • La vitre n'est pas fusionnée à l'écran LCD.
  • Il faut un pistolet à air chaud pour remplacer le LCD.

8
iPad 3 4G
iPad 3 4G
  • Just like the iPad 2, the front panel is glued to the rest of the device, greatly increasing the chances of cracking the glass when trying to remove it.
  • Gobs, gobs, and gobs of adhesive hold down everything in place, including the prone-to-start-a-fire-if-punctured battery.
  • The LCD has foam sticky tape adhering it to the front panel, increasing chances of the front panel being shattered during disassembly

2
Nook Tablet
Nook Tablet
  • The LCD is not fused to the front panel assembly, making replacement easy, if necessary.
  • Hidden screws prevent removal of rear panel.
  • Excessive amount of adhesive and adhesive strips make disassembly a painfully tedious process.

6
Kindle Fire
Kindle Fire
  • The rear case is very easy to open, granting trouble-free access to the internals.
  • All the fasteners found inside are Phillips #0 screws—one non-proprietary screwdriver is all you need.
  • The glass panel is fused to the front plastic frame, meaning a heat gun is required for replacing cracked glass (or you have to replace both components together).

8
iPad 2 Wi-Fi EMC 2415
iPad 2 Wi-Fi EMC 2415
  • The front panel is now glued to the rest of the device, greatly increasing the chances of cracking the glass when trying to remove it.
  • The LCD has foam sticky tape adhering it to the front panel, increasing chances of it being shattered during disassembly.
  • The battery is very securely stuck down to rear case, and you have to remove the logic board to remove it.

2
Motorola Xoom
Motorola Xoom
  • There's no proprietary screws or fasteners in the machine -- everything comes out with a spudger and a couple of Torx screwdrivers.
  • LCD and front panel glass are not fused together. That's great news for folks unfortunate enough to drop their Xooms and crack their glass.
  • Everything is accessible but somewhat inconvenient to repair -- there's just a lot of labor involved with removing that many screws.

8
Dell Streak
Dell Streak
  • Good: Replacing the battery is super easy and takes less than one minute.
  • Good: Opening the device requires prying the bezels and removing five screws.
  • Bad: The LCD is bonded to the Gorilla Glass, increasing the cost of fixing the device if you break just the glass.

8
Réparation iPad Wi-Fi
Réparation iPad Wi-Fi
  • Front panel is held in place with clips.
  • LCD is not fused to the display glass.
  • Battery is difficult to remove and replace.

6

蜀ICP备17039037号