Is the iPhone XS screen compatible with the iPhone X?

I’ve got an iPhone X with a broken screen, and a locked iPhone XS with a working screen, after some googling i found that the XS screen will work on an X, although i couldn’t find any video proof of it fully working, when i tried, the top half of the digitizer didn’t work, i put it back on the XS and it worked fine, is this just the incompatibility of the XS screen on the X? Or is something else wrong? I tried the X screen on the X and the touch worked fine, ive tried reseating and making sure it’s connected properly many times, im really stumped, has anyone here successfully tried that?